Autumn is one of the best times to start composting, thanks to fallen leaves and garden clippings that are rich in carbon and organic matter. Instead of bagging up that yard waste, you can turn it into nutrient-dense compost that helps feed your garden in the months ahead.

While dropping temperatures can slow decomposition, your compost pile doesn’t have to go dormant. According to experts, the right balance of materials, moisture and seasonal preparation can keep the process moving well into winter.

“Fall is the right time to start because there’s more leaves and cut-offs now than any other time of year, and it’s still warm enough for the compost to get going,” says Jacob Bradbury, CEO of Derbyshire Walling & Landscaping.

Here’s how to build an autumn compost pile to nourish your garden when warmer weather returns.

How to Start a Compost Pile in Fall: Step-by-Step

1. Choose the Right Spot for Your Compost Pile

Before you begin gathering leaves and grass clippings, decide where your compost will live. A level spot with good drainage is your best choice, especially if it’s easy to reach from your kitchen and garden. You’ll also want enough room to access the pile with a wheelbarrow.

Direct contact with soil matters, too. Bradbury recommends placing compost on the ground rather than on decking or paving slabs. This allows worms and other soil organisms to move into the pile while excess water drains away.

Get More of Our News on Google

Set The Weather Company as a 'Preferred Source' to get quicker access to the news you value.

A partially shaded location is ideal. This is because too much direct sunlight can dry out compost, while a cold, damp spot in full shade can slow decomposition.

You’ll also want to decide between an enclosed bin or open pile. A bin can help keep the area tidy while making it harder for pests to access your compost. With either setup, aim for a pile that’s at least three feet wide. A larger pile retains moisture and generates internal heat that supports decomposition as temperatures drop.

2. Balance Your Greens and Browns

The right mix of green and brown materials is key to successful composting. Greens provide nitrogen, while browns supply carbon. Both are essential for microorganisms that break down organic matter.

For greens, collect fresh grass clippings, vegetable peels, coffee grounds and soft garden trimmings. Browns include dry fallen leaves, straw, shredded cardboard and dried garden debris.

Aim for two-to-three parts brown material to one part green material by volume. It’s easy to go overboard with leaves in autumn, but too many browns can slow decomposition.

“One of my favorite autumn composting tricks is to keep a separate stash of dry, shredded leaves beside the compost pile,” says Siobhan Shaw, co-founder of Growing to Give. “Kitchen scraps continue coming through winter, but gardeners often run out of browns when they need them most.”

Shredding leaves before adding them to the pile can also make a difference. Whole leaves mat together when wet, which restricts airflow and slows decomposition. Running over them with a lawn mower can break them into smaller pieces. Mowing up leaves along with the last grass clippings of the season also creates a useful mix of green and brown materials.

3. Layer Your Materials and Keep Them Moist

Once you’ve gathered your materials, it’s time to build. Start with a few inches of coarse material like small twigs or woody prunings to promote airflow and drainage. Then add alternating layers of greens and browns while keeping the green layers thinner.

Your pile shouldn’t feel waterlogged, but rather like a wrung-out sponge. If it feels dry, add water. Cover it loosely with a tarp or weighted cardboard in rainy weather to prevent sogginess.

4. Protect Your Pile as Temperatures Drop

Microorganisms become less active as winter approaches, and it’s totally normal for the outside of your pile to freeze. That’s why ensuring your pile is at least three feet wide helps it retain heat in its center to allow decomposition to continue through colder weather.

“Continue to add kitchen scraps and dry leaves to help retain heat,” says Jessica Mercer, horticulturist at Plant Addicts.

If the weather is mild, turn the pile every few weeks to add oxygen. As temperatures drop, turn it less often to help retain heat. If the pile freezes, wait until it thaws before turning it.

5. Avoid Common Composting Mistakes

Keep meat, fish, dairy, grease and oily foods out of your pile, since they can attract pests and create unpleasant odors. You’ll also want to skip pet waste, diseased plants, weeds that have gone to seed and chemically treated yard waste.

Check the moisture level regularly, too. A soggy pile can develop odors, while one that’s too dry won’t break down properly. If your compost smells rotten instead of earthy, this is a sign it may need more airflow and dry material to help balance the moisture.

“The most common mistakes are adding too many greens or browns at once and keeping the pile either too wet or too dry,” Mercer says. Of course, making the pile too small can also lead to rapid heat and moisture loss, which is another composting mistake gardeners tend to make. 

6. Know When Your Compost Is Ready

An autumn compost pile can take six months to a year to mature. Timing will depend on its size, ingredients and winter temperatures.

“Finished compost is dark, crumbly and earthy smelling,” Mercer says. Most original materials should no longer be recognizable, and the compost should have a mild, soil-like scent.

Once your compost is ready, work it into garden beds to enrich the soil ahead of the growing season. If it’s not completely finished by spring, give it more time. The leaves you saved during autumn cleanup will eventually become a valuable foundation for your garden next spring.

Sources:

• Jacob Bradbury, CEO of Derbyshire Walling & Landscaping
• Siobhan Shaw, Co-founder of Growing to Give
• Jessica Mercer, Horticulturist at Plant Addicts

Related: Are You Over-Fertilizing? Signs Your Plants Are Getting Too Much